Scriptorium Archive
for January, 2010

Plato for Pleasure

Fred Sanders | Philosophy | 01.29.2010

Hey, everybody, Plato is fun! Everybody ought to read him! Yay Plato! That, at least, is the argument of Adam Fox in his 1945 book Plato for Pleasure (revised edtion 1962). "The works of Plato have generally been in the hands of philosophers and scholars when they ought to have been in the hands of the people," laments Fox. He doesn't think that 30 million Brits are going to head off to their beach holidays with Plato ... Read More...

Menand: Uncommonly Successful in Keeping the Felicities of Prose

Fred Sanders | Philosophy, Literature | 01.27.2010

I just finished a very fast read-through (with permission to skip some sections) of Louis Menand's Pulitzer Prize-winning 2001 book The Metaphysical Club: A Story of Ideas in America. It's a 500-page book about one school of American philosophy. I picked it up used and have had it on the shelf for a few years, waiting until my teaching duties called for me to brush up on pragmatism. The time came at last --John Dewey must... Read More...

Additional Scriptorium for January, 2010

Making the Most of The Shack

Fred Sanders | Theology | 01.27.2010

How should a theologian respond to a popular book that includes unsound teaching? The popular book I'm thinking of is The Shack, by William P. Young. After getting dozens of questions about The Shack, I wrote a review of it in early 2009. Actually, I wrote five reviews of it, in five different voices, partly so nobody could accuse me of not understanding that IT'S JUST A STORY... Read More...

Sleep Talkin’ Theologian 4: “Translucent in Honor, Suspended in Dignity.”

Fred Sanders | Misc., Theology | 01.25.2010

And here is the epic conclusion to my sleep-talking adventures from graduate school. (Click here for installments 1, 2, and 3.) I'm sure I still talk in my sleep, but probably not as much as back in the day. During the time my wife took these notes, I was reading assigned theology all day every day, staying up late into the night, and hating to get out of bed. At any rate, t... Read More...

Sleep Talkin’ Theologian 3: “Like a Light Beam In A Hallway.”

Fred Sanders | Misc., Theology | 01.25.2010

Installment 3 of 4 in this series of transcripts of my sleep-talking adventures from the late 90s. No, I cannot explain most of these. *** Something about a surgeon Getting ready to cut something out of someone [who?] Part of the time it was me. Part of the time it was some guy I didn’t know. [Is he a good surgeon?] Yes. *** Some motivational speaker. He’... Read More...

Sleep Talkin’ Theologian 2: “Looks Like Birds But It’s Really An Angel.”

Fred Sanders | Misc., Theology | 01.24.2010

Transcript 2 of 4 in the annals of the sleep-talkin' theologian. These notes date from about 1997. My long-suffering wife, a morning person, asks me questions like "when do you want to wake up?" and "what are you dreaming about?" Still asleep, I answer her questions. Sometimes she interjects ideas into my dreams, and I accept them. She's especially fond of lobbing kittens in. ... Read More...

Sleep Talkin’ Theologian: “How Long Will Ye Linger Between Two Cabinets?”

Fred Sanders | Misc., Theology | 01.23.2010

There's a man in England, Adam Lennard, who talks in his sleep. He speaks very clearly, says truly bizarre things, and is recorded by his wife's voice-activated digital recorder. His wife has begun blogging his nightly oracles, and their blog is suddenly the Next Big Thing: millions of readers, interviews on talk shows, merchandise, the whole viral internet treatment. Check out... Read More...

Why Taiwan is more Chinese than China

Allen Yeh | Culture | 01.21.2010

Taipei 101 skyscraper, modeled on the shape of bamboo Today is the last day of my two-week stay in Taiwan, visiting relatives. Taiwan is often overlooked by Westerners in favor of China. My mother is from China and my father is from Taiwan, but I want to argue that Taiwan is more Chinese than China. If you want to experience China at its fullest, go to Taiwan, not China! ... Read More...

An Excerpt From “Education for Human Flourishing”

Paul Spears | Philosophy, Education, Theology | 01.18.2010

To follow up Fred Sanders' review of my book I have posted a short excerpt from Education for Human Flourishing published by IVP Academic. The passage below describes the difference between rhetoric and knowledge, and how important it is for us to be able to distinguish between the two. Rhetoric Versus Knowledge It is easy to feel defeated and confused given daily cultur... Read More...

MLK: “To Go Forward, We’ve Got To Go Back.”

Fred Sanders | Culture | 01.18.2010

The greatest works of Martin Luther King, Jr. are the "I have a dream" sermon and the "Letter from a Birmingham Jail." These are MLK at his best, when his preparation and his personal struggles lined up providentially with the turbulent events of the civil rights movement, and he found all the right words to say what needed to be said. Take up and read. But King also produc... Read More...

Gotta Be Dominos

John Mark Reynolds | Culture | 01.17.2010

The Constitution of 1789 and republican values. Ronald Reagan and tax cuts. Orthodoxy and icons. Some things go together naturally and pizza and NFL play-off football are two naturals. Over the course of my life no pizza was more guaranteed to disappoint than Domino's. It was as fake as Ben Nelson's hair. If you saw the box at a pizza party, you went for any other foot... Read More...

The Baptism of Christ: 9, The Holy Spirit

Fred Sanders | Art, Theology | 01.15.2010

In one sense, portraying the Holy Spirit in baptism icons is not a problem at all: the Spirit descended in the form of a dove. The iconographer does not need to try to get behind this simple assertion of the New Testament to ask "why a dove?" For the most part, painters just seem grateful to have been given a concrete, visible way of depicting this most mysterious and elusive... Read More...

Ignorance allows certainty, but punishes with narrowness

John Mark Reynolds | Culture, Theology | 01.14.2010

Ignorance allows certainty, but punishes with narrowness. Ignorance grants ease of mind, but produces costly errors. No place is this more evident in American culture than in those ignorant of Christianity. They think they know what Christians believe, but do not. They cheerfully dismiss with almost no thought serious truth claims made by religious thinkers. They revel in th... Read More...

Should the Earth This Moment Cleave

Fred Sanders | Theology | 01.13.2010

In 1750, after two earthquakes hit England, Charles Wesley wrote two small volumes of hymns on earthquakes. It is not too much to say that he developed a whole theology of earthquakes, in song. They answer the question, when a believer's country is struck by such a disaster, what should that believer say, or sing, to God? Here is hymn #5 from the first collection. Go... Read More...